Cody, Wyoming — Buffalo Bill’s hometown and the lively gateway to East Yellowstone — serves up cowboy-style steaks, hearty breakfasts and surprising ethnic spots with genuine Western hospitality. Locals and travelers consistently praise places like WyThai and Trailhead, though nights, seasons and staffing can change the experience.
Based on Reddit discussions, travel forums, and local blogs.
Locals and travelers consistently recommend WyThai, Trailhead, 8th Street at The Ivy, Our Place Cafe, and several steakhouses/BBQ spots for solid meals; these are often praised for authenticity, brunch options, breakfast, and cowboy-style fare. However, experiences can vary by night, season, and staffing — several places (e.g., WyoDough, Proud Cut, Bubba’s) have mixed reviews, and a few establishments (Cassie’s, The Meatery, The Breadboard, Millstone, Green River Bar) drew explicit warnings or recent negative reports.
Overall sentiment: positive
Locals call it a hidden gem and the best Thai in town — authentic flavors and friendly owners. Expect some wait time because the same kitchen handles dine-in and takeout.
"I'll die on the hill that WyThai is the best restaurant in Cody."
"That place is an absolute hidden gem. Damn good Thai food and super friendly owners!"
Sources: reddit.com · restaurantjump.com · tastingtable.com
Overall sentiment: positive
Recommended as a solid, somewhat upscale option — popular for dinner and weekend brunch with creative dishes.
"Trailhead or 8th Street at the Ivy!"
"trailhead is awesome, and they offer an amazing brunch on the weekends."
Sources: reddit.com · tripadvisor.com
Overall sentiment: positive
Consistent, clean, and reliably good for breakfast/lunch/dinner — a safe choice for visitors wanting dependable food.
"8th Street at the Ivy is a GREAT choice. it's clean and consistent. everything is fresh and well made."
Sources: reddit.com · tripadvisor.com
Overall sentiment: mixed
Locals praise the pizzas, burgers and chicken, but there are mixed opinions and past complaints about premade crusts and ownership/recipe changes.
"WyoDough has some amazing pizzas, burgers, and chicken."
"Even if you don't care for the pizza, the burgers and chicken are absofuckinglutely amazing.. especially with their hot honey bbq."
Sources: reddit.com
Overall sentiment: positive
Consistently recommended for hearty breakfasts — many visitors and TripAdvisor reviewers call it a must for morning meals.
"We had breakfast here two days in a row."
Sources: tripadvisor.com · codylodgingcompany.com
Overall sentiment: mixed
Known for 'cowboy cuisine' (big steaks, Rocky Mountain oysters, burgers). Many rave, but some report occasional overcooked or burnt steaks — experiences vary.
"By far the Proud Cut outshined the other restaurants we ate at. Great food"
Sources: tripadvisor.com · reddit.com
Overall sentiment: mixed
Popular traveler pick for BBQ (brisket, ribs, salad bar) with many positive reviews, though some longtime locals say quality has fluctuated over the years.
Sources: tripadvisor.com · tripadvisor.com
Overall sentiment: mixed
Visited for its historic setting and novelty (Buffalo Bill’s Irma Hotel). Good for atmosphere and classic menu items, but service/food quality can be inconsistent.
"The Irma is "famous" for the hotel bar and historic atmosphere."
Sources: tastingtable.com · tripadvisor.com
Overall sentiment: mixed
A go-to for steak dinners as expected in beef country; TripAdvisor ranks it highly but reviews and Reddit comments show mixed experiences (some overcooked steaks).
Sources: tripadvisor.com · reddit.com
Overall sentiment: positive
Frequently recommended for casual meals with good burgers and local beer — a common pick for relaxed evenings.
Sources: tripadvisor.com · tripadvisor.com
Overall sentiment: positive
Gets praise for Mediterranean/Turkish dishes (çoban salad, lamb) and is listed among locals' favorites.
"Sittis, trailhead, 8th st (blackened salmon salad is soooooo good), wythai"
Sources: tastingtable.com · reddit.com
Overall sentiment: positive
Noted for decent sushi and chicken katsu; some visitors praise authenticity and owners.
Sources: tastingtable.com · reddit.com
Overall sentiment: negative
Several Reddit threads discuss alleged criminal behavior by owners (chasing/threatening customers) and locals strongly recommend avoiding and not supporting the business.
"you can go to Cassie’s but you shouldn’t support those assholes for threatening to kill customers and assaulting police officers."
Sources: reddit.com · reddit.com
Overall sentiment: negative
Mentioned on Reddit as a place to avoid due to a commentator describing food and hygiene issues; listed among smaller places with mixed or negative feedback.
Sources: reddit.com
Overall sentiment: negative
At least one detailed TripAdvisor criticism called it overpriced and reported poor food temperature; an example of negative local feedback.
"overpriced"
"cold soup"
Sources: tripadvisor.com
Overall sentiment: negative
A recent TripAdvisor review complained of overcooked food and staffing issues; experiences appear to vary but this is a noted recent negative example.
"overcooked food & staffing problems"
Sources: tripadvisor.com
Overall sentiment: negative
Reddit posts allege controversial or problematic behavior tied to this bar; locals suggest checking recent threads/reviews before visiting.
Sources: reddit.com
Hours, directions, and contact info for restaurants in Cody.
1192 Sheridan Ave, Cody, WY 82414, USA
Hotel, restaurant & saloon established by Buffalo Bill in 1902 with both historic & standard rooms.
1550 Sheridan Ave, Cody, WY 82414, USA
Homestyle American meals are served up from early morning to night in a relaxed space with a patio.
Open now
1227 Sheridan Ave, Cody, WY 82414, USA
Buffalo burgers & traditional American classics lure locals at this casual hangout with a full bar.
Open now
2005 17th St, Cody, WY 82414, USA
Classic, long-running fast-food chain known for its burgers & fries.
Open now
1326 Beck Ave, Cody, WY 82414, USA
Laid-back eatery serving Italian cuisine such as wood-fried pies, pastas, veggies & meat dishes.
Open now
1800 8th St, Cody, WY 82414, USA
Contemporary hotel restaurant offering American fare, plus a cozy bar & a patio.
Closed
1910 Demaris Dr, Cody, WY 82414, USA
Sizable, vibrant locale featuring a homestyle American buffet & a live country-western music show.
Closed
1192 Sheridan Ave, Cody, WY 82414, USA
Prime rib house with a full bar & seasonal buffets in a historic hotel built by Buffalo Bill.
Open now
1057 Sheridan Ave, Cody, WY 82414, USA
Italian grub & craft beer served in a spacious, relaxed tavern with flat-screen TVs & arcade games.
Open now
1456 Sheridan Ave, Cody, WY 82414, USA
Fast-food burger chain serving sides such as chili & baked potatoes.
Closed
